Judging Amy: Season 2


# Air Date Title
1 Oct 10

Zero Tolerance

As the Gray family tries to cope with the aftermath of the explosion, Maxine cuts back on her workload to help Vincent through his difficult recovery, while Amy realizes that s…

2 Oct 24

You're Not the Boss of Me

Maxine goes overboard in mothering Vincent after he’s released from the hospital and moves back into her house to recuperate; Amy sentences a teenager accused of bullying…

3 Oct 31


Vincent returns to work; Gillian nervously agrees to allow Donna to babysit for Ned so that she and Peter can have a romantic wedding anniversary celebration; Amy takes an inst…

4 Nov 14


Amy contends with a high profile attorney who attempts to bully her during a paternity case; Maxine struggles over mending fences with a neighbor; Vincent’s near-death ex…

5 Nov 21

Unnecessary Roughness

Amy seeks to have Lauren qualified as a ““gifted”“ student; Maxine agrees to take a anger management class after going too far in insulting a coworker a…

6 Nov 28

The Burden of Perspective

Amy is as shocked as Lauren is pleased to learn of Michael and Leisha’s impending wedding; sensing that Maxine has reservations about their relationship, Jared suggests t…

7 Dec 05

Dog Days

Amy must decide whether to remove an eleven year old girl from the custody of her Wanderer parents; Vincent writes an article criticizing the foster care system which gets a fr…

8 Dec 19


When Donna’s birthing center burns down the night before she goes into labor, the Grays offer the use of their house for her baby’s water birth; the family becomes…

9 Jan 09

The Undertow

Amy gets to know Rob, Lauren’s very attractive sensei, better when he brings Lauren home from class after Amy has forgotten to pick her up; Maxine finds some powerful al…

10 Jan 16

Adoption Day

Evie walks back into Ned’s life just as Peter and Gillian are set to adopt him; Maxine deals with a young girl who wants to be adopted before her 18th birthday, and a 12-…

11 Jan 30

The Claw is Our Master

Amy finds herself in the middle of a love triangle when she considers giving Tom Gillette a second chance while she continues to date Rob; Maxine investigates the case of a boy…

12 Feb 06

8 1/2 Narrow

Amy finds herself fending off Nick’s advances and agonizes over whether she should tell Lolly; Maxine assists a detective in tracking down an undocumented Cambodian boy&#…

13 Feb 13

The Beginning, the End, and the Murky Middle

As Peter and Gillian prepare for Ned’s christening, Evie returns to claim her son; Amy and Tom decide to make their relationship public; Carole has trouble dealing with V…

14 Feb 20

One For the Road

Peter and Gillian lose custody of Ned to Evie; Peter tries to drown his grief in alcohol and is arrested for drunk driving; Gillian fixates on Peter’s drinking to avoid d…

15 Feb 27

The Treachery of Compromise

Representing the governor, Stuart Collins offers Amy a chance to apply for an appellate court appointment if she’ll rule against two women who both want to be named as th…

16 Mar 20

Everybody Falls Down

Amy must decide whether to terminate the parental rights of a couple convicted of child abuse; Maxine’s disrespect rubs a building inspector the wrong way, endangering th…

17 Apr 10

Romeo and Juliet Must Die--Well, Maybe Just Juliet

Amy hears a manslaughter case involving a 15-year-old boy who’s into goth and accused of luring a girl into a mutual suicide pact; Maxine investigates allegations that a…

18 Apr 24

The Unforgiven

Maxine contemplates ending her relationship with Jared after meeting his son again, while Amy oversees a case involving a mother who wants to deny visitation rights to her daug…

19 May 01

Between the Wanting and the Getting

Jonathan Ashworth joins the Sanctuary House team and manages to ruffle everyone’s feathers; Amy tries unsuccessfully to displace some doubts about her relationship with R…

20 May 08


Felled by the flu, Amy collapses in court, but not before presiding over a custody hearing for a cow; long-buried feelings erupt between Gillian and Peter when Evie offers to r…

21 May 15

Redheaded Stepchild

The Sanctuary House staff works together to determine the identity of the adult who molested a twelve year old boy who confessed to raping his five year old sister; after Bruce…

22 May 22

Hold on Tight

Maxine reunites a couple with their kidnapped baby; Vincent is upset when Carole usurps his prerogative to tell his family about their move in his own way and time by blurting…

About Judging Amy